The Macalope suppose it ’s genuine of other companies , but Apple seems to attract dubious analytic thinking like mustaches to Rob Enderle ’s side . This hebdomad a couple of ZDNet bloggers finally catch up with the repose of us while surveys bode a Kindle Fire - y doom for the iPad … or do they?Finally , Consumer Reports still does n’t get the iPhone 4S.
Better late than never
In another sign of how Android is set to win the tablet distance — some day , just you wait!—two extremity of the ZDNet brain trust have flip-flop .
What ’s that ?
Oh . The Macalope is being inform that they actually switchedfromAndroid - based tabletstothe iPad . Hang on a second while the Macalope rewrite his billet and hahaha , no , he have intercourse that , of course — why else would he be bringing it up ?
First up isJames Kendrick .
I have used at least a dozen dissimilar Android tablets in addition to the two I own . I use tablets heavily , and have grow increasingly frustrated over the inconsistent user experience . That is why I just bribe an iPad 2 .
You do n’t say . Well , that is shocking . The Macalope had heard that Android lozenge were just as good as iPads and also come with 4 G and USB keyboards and stuff . Correct the horny one if he ’s ill-timed , but it appear that what you ’re saying is that user experience matters more than just check out boxes off on a list of features . Who . Could . Have . Guessed ?
understand more …
pad of paper are very personal equipment as they are used in the hands . Laggy performance , inconsistent app controls , and long app onus time add up to a jarring , annoying user experience .
No , no , no . Jim , Jim , Jim . It ’s point on a checklist . sooner with gullible halt and red X ’s . And the Android pill has checks next to such iPad - killing point as “ stylus ” and “ Flash ” while the iPad has red X ’s .
The computer hardware is typical Apple lineament , and the software works as expected . It is smooth and snappy , and already impacting my work in a positive way . It just works .
Whatever , Apple zealot .
Next up is Stephen Chapman , whotried pad of paper back in Augustand limit they were not . For . Him . No , sir , they were not .
Since the launch of the iPad , a act of company put out their own tablets at significantly lower price points than the iPad , so I resolve it was time to do the deal and feed the monster inside of me that craved a tablet . And just what did I decide to buy , you ask ? Good question ! I went with a NOOK Color …
And , long story shortsighted , the Macalope knows you ’ll observe this hard to consider , but he was not impressed . Astounding !
All - in - all , I ’ve all cured myself of tablet enviousness ! Now , when I see someone with an iPad or something of the sort , I reckon to myself , “ achiever ! ”
Well done , Stephen . And , yet , “ tablets ” extend to be a arise intersection category . How to excuse this other than aggregated hysteria ?
Fast forward to November and Stephen ’s decided to give the iPad a effort and judge what?He absolutely loves it !
My iPad has wholly demolish the sensing of myself as an individual who would n’t make use of a tablet twist . It has also totally destroyed my notion of any other pill out there standing a chance of compete against not just the equipment , but the app ecosystem and Io on a tablet equipment .
ZDNet : the latest in last class ’s engineering psychoanalysis ! If only someone could have tell you that in Augustof 2010and saved you the $ 250 you wasted on the Nook in 2011 . OH , WELL .
All irony away , congratulation ! Welcome to April of 2010 , ZDNet bloggers . You ’ve finally come to the realization the rest of us came to a yr and a one-half ago .
OK , maybe notallsarcasm apart .
Misfire
Despite the view of Apple executives to the opposite , some seem to conceive that the Amazon Kindle will have a big shock on iPad gross sales . The Macalope really does n’t know how this will run out , but so far the evidence is thin than an iPad 2 .
For starters , there ’s thedevastatingChangeWave surveythat ’s been floating around
2,600 other adopter were canvass , of which 5 per centum indicated they were either very potential to buy a Kindle Fire or had already pre - ordered one . That pct exceeds the 4 pct who were design to buy the iPad 1 before its 2010 release .
Right . When pad were such a hot and proven intersection line .
Within the 5 percentage group , 26 pct said they would detain or put on hold any plans to get an iPad .
So , ofthe people who wereverylikely to orhad already ordereda Kindle Fire , 5 percent — a sum of 130 people — were holding off on buying an iPad .
withering .
Did the multitude wave this view around in reality study it ?
This is n’t the first exercise in theatrical about the panorama for an Apple product that ChangeWave has undertaken . Nor would it be the first clip that the business firm was onthe wrong side of a trend . What ’s the point of putting out a survey if no one inter-group communication to it ?
Which brings us to our old pals atRetrevo ; they want in this plot , too . Their results say a humongous 44 per centum of citizenry interested in buy a pad would consider the Kindle Fire instead of an iPad !
This resume was of 1000 multitude , 69 pct of whom said they were pill - queer — which think of that all of 304 people surveyed said they’dconsidera Kindle Fire . Meanwhile , 12 percent said “ If you bother me again while I ’m standing in line at this Apple Store trying to grease one’s palms an iPad , I ’m anticipate surety ” and another 44 percent said “ Kindle whatnow ? ”
It ’s not just view scallywag ( not associate with Survey Monkey , void where prohibited ) forebode Kindle Fire doom for the iPad , asCNet ’s Brooke Crother ’s explain :
Two enquiry notes today paint a picture that Amazon ’s upcoming Kindle Fire tablet might retard the heady sales event growth of Apple ’s iPad .
The first is the aforementioned ChangeWave survey . The 2d is even more dubious :
And a separate news report today from Rodman & Renshaw ’s Ashok Kumar claims that iPad momentum is slack . “ Our checks argue that output volumes have been scale back due to moderating sell - through . We judge that iPad volumes in the current one-fourth will be 12 - 13 million units , ” down from late estimates of 14 million to 15 million , Kumar wrote .
Hmm . Ashok Kumar . Ashok Kumar . Where has the Macalopeheard that name before ?
Oh , right , he ’s the hombre who said a whole mess of ridiculous clobber about the iPad over the last two geezerhood that was all prostrate - out improper : 7 - column inch blind , would launch with 3 gm financial support from Verizon , would be a “ niche product , ” etc . , etc .
So , let ’s just take it as judicial writ that the Bible of Ashok Kumar and $ 2.50 at Starbucks will not even get you a loving cup of deep brown , because the barista would be like “ Word of Ashok Kumar ? You get the hell out of here . ”
Hey , the Macalope does n’t have intercourse how many purchaser the Kindle Fire will syphon off from the iPad . There has to be some real intersection between people interested in the iPad and those interested in the Kindle Fire . Heck , the Macalope is mildly concerned in the Kindle Fire ( although he ’d never buy oneinsteadof an iPad , just in accession to ) .
So far , however , there really has n’t been much to dispel the opinion that these are mostly two disjoined classes of pad of paper .
Saturday Special: Check!
Consumer Reportsfinally took the scarlet letter—”A , ” for “ Antenna”—off of the iPhone in its ratings this week , but the bestselling phone still does n’t get the top nod from the publishing that your parents used to plunk that microwave with the dials back in the 1970s .
But it ’s clock time to put the pain because of “ Antennagate ” behind us and move ahead into a brilliant future where we ask “ Nowwhat ’s upConsumer Reports ’s butt ? ”
These pluses were not enough , however , to admit the iPhone 4S to outscore the best new Android - based phones in our Ratings . Those top scorers admit the Samsung Galaxy S II phones , the Motorola Droid Bionic , and several other phones that shoot a line large showing than the iPhone 4S and hunt down on faster 4 G connection .
…
Other phones that topped the iPhone 4S let in the LG Thrill ( $ 100 on AT&T ) , which has the ability to capture stills and videos in 3D , as well as expose them on its 4.3 - inch 3D exhibit , and the Motorola Droid Bionic ( $ 300 on Verizon ) , which also has a brilliant 4.3 - inch , mellow - resolution ( 540 x 960 ) display , with excellent computer keyboard readability under most kindling conditions , even in shiny light .
Consumer Reportshas a features list and it ’s checking it twice . Larger screen ? chink ! Keypad legibility ? Check ! television in 3D ? turn back !
Videos in 3D?Other recap call it a “ gimmick,”but forConsumer Reportsit ’s enough for the Thrill to get a nod over the iPhone 4S. avowedly , the Macalope has a complete and perfect diagonal against 3D ( perhaps because the crank never tally decent on him since his eyes are a Classic Mac screen ) but , really , how many hoi polloi even need a 3D covert on their speech sound ? If you switch a bottle screw on an Android earpiece , Consumer Reportswould give you a hindrance for “ Corkscrew ” and give the iPhone a red X.
This checklist method may make the job of write comparative pillar easier , but it does n’t result to well decision - making — a ripe user experience is about more than a checklist of feature . Fortunately , consumers know this , just not the cartridge holder that purpose to represent them .
