Expert’s Rating
Pros
Cons
Our Verdict
Unless you have an dynamic interest in produce podcasts or creating a melodious score , it ’s likely you ’ve open GarageBand once and then never bothered with it again . Of all the programs that make up the iLife suite , none is more overlooked than this lotion . And , given its original nidus , that ’s not too surprising . Making euphony postulate a skill not coarse in the general population of computing equipment user .
And so , with each version , Apple assay to explore a unlike slant , hop to bring in a new audience for GarageBand . Two version ago , with GarageBand 3 ( ) , it was podcasting . In GarageBand ’ 08 ( ) , Apple introduced Magic GarageBand , a feature that allows you to jam along with a canned dance band . With GarageBand ’ 09 , the novel lure is guitar and piano lesson — nine basic lessons for bud musician as well as a fistful of optional artist object lesson for learning specific call by such well - known musicians as Norah Jones , John Fogerty , and Sting .
Veteran GarageBand users who ’ve already mastered their axes are n’t go away out of the mix . Guitar player now have the chance to dally through five freshly modeled amplifiers and a host of stomp box audio frequency effects . player who were frustrated by Magic GarageBand ’s inability to record what they noodled will be pleased to determine that transcription is now part of the magic . And , disregardless of who open up the practical app , user will discover a redesign port that makes exist features easier to find .
You can view the instructor, instrument, and music in a variety of ways.
Lessons learned
The marquee characteristic of GarageBand ’ 09 is watch to Play , the practical program ’s basic and artist pianissimo and guitar picture lesson . GarageBand ’ 09 include the first introductory guitar and piano lessons . you’re able to obtain eight additional free lesson for each instrument by choose the Lesson Store entry in the New Project windowpane , pick out the Basic Lessons tablet , and then clicking the Download button next to the lessons you want to download from the Internet . creative person lesson are obtained likewise , but be $ 5 each . Unfortunately , these lessons work only on Intel Macs with a double - core central processor , though the rest of GarageBand ’ 09 make for with PowerPC - based Macs .
Each introductory guitar and piano moral is taught by “ Tim , ” an approachable instructor who begins with the physical layout of each instrument and , in later deterrent example , walks through the basics of playing the instruments . For the piano lesson this include bequeath and right mitt notes and fingering , sharps and apartment , rhythm , major and minor chord , and scales . The guitar lesson let in basic major and minor chords , major and minor barre chords , strumming , exclusive government note melodies , and superpower chords .
Nearly every object lesson ends with a song that you ’re welcome to play along with . Each lesson also include a child’s play section that admit you to play along with the instructor ( and register what you act ) . The lesson are nicely produced , well paced , and salute in a style that you’re able to easily zero in on exactly what you ’d care to see . you could , for example , apply the Mac ’s number keys to switch views . In the piano example , nigh every scene includes Tim at the top of the windowpane and a keyboard at the bottom . But you could switch views to see the threefold clef , freshwater bass clef , grand staff ( both clefs ) , or chords in between Tim and the keyboard . In the guitar object lesson , there ’s Tim above and a fretboard below with switchable position that include guitar chord boxes , chord , tablature , and notational system . Lefties can also change the predilection of the fretboard at the bottom of the screen .
The new Electric Guitar tracks support modeled amps and stomp box effects.
you may view the instructor , tool , and music in a variety of way .
When Tim plays , you’re able to see what he ’s playing reflected on the piano keyboard or fretboard at the bottom of the screen — when he place his third digit on atomic number 99 above middle C , for example , a blue 3 appears on the keyboard ’s E key . It works similarly on the fretboard — when he fingers a chord , those frets consort with the chord make a dreary Zen and the strummed string oscillate .
When you secure a MIDI keyboard into your Mac , it becomes available to GarageBand , allowing you to play a piano sound within the lessons . If you ’re using a guitar , you severalise GarageBand whether you have an electric guitar plugged into an audio interface attached to your Mac or you ’re using an acoustical guitar and a mike . GarageBand will record it accordingly . you could swap on a metronome as well as slow down the speed of the medicine so it ’s promiscuous to play in clock time ( when you align the pace , Tim ’s phonation is muffle ) . you may also deepen the speech sound mix , adjusting the instructor ’s voice , teacher ’s tool , the band ( and each cat’s-paw within the band ) , and the loudness of your instrument . you’re able to also coil sections of lessons so you’re able to repeatedly practice them .
Magic GarageBand now lets you record your part and mix the band.
The Artist lessons are just as beautiful to look at and volunteer the same kind of interactivity . The teaching ability of the artist varies — some are more thorough teacher than others . Norah Jones , for example , speaks as if she ’s had courtly musical education and explain the way she voices her chord by describing their position ( radical , first , or second position ) . One Republic ’s Ryan Tedder does n’t offer this level of particular but rather prove you how he plays a particular chord . bunco game assumes you have a go at it how to make more complex chord on the guitar and so simply tells you the chord name and shows you how to feel them . Not surprisingly , none of the artists completely harmonize on technique so you may see them do something — finger a chord , for example — that contradicts something Tim has taught you .
Some of the creative person lessons are offer up in both Simple and Advanced versions , allowing both lead off and experient musicians to get some delectation from them . And each artist moral includes a video of the artist talk about the song or another bailiwick tight to their heart . ( Norah Jones does n’t touch on her birdsong at all , for example , but rather discusses the advantage of cart a relatively portable Wurlitzer electric piano to a gig versus the back - break Fender Rhodes . )
Getting you started
GarageBand ’s approach to teaching piano and guitar is an challenging one — providing enough information to have you play a song as quickly as possible . It ’s a great plan of attack for give nascent players the sort of achiever they need to keep at it , but there are compromises as well . Some subject are n’t covered very deep and , of course , there ’s no one stand up over you to check on what you ’re doing . But depth is n’t what Learn to Play is about . Rather , it ’s a start pointedness for learning to learn how to meet .
Fortunately , you have other choices as GarageBand ’ 09 is n’t the only instructional biz in town . you could get more in - astuteness computer - base object lesson fromiPlayMusic , iPerform3D , andeMedia Music . AndiVideosongsoffers some beautifully take creative person deterrent example . ( I discuss some of these and other instructional method in Learn to Play an Instrument . ) Of naturally , there ’s still no substitute for a real instructor who can give you customized assignments base on your ability .
Rock on
In previous versions of GarageBand , you could recreate real instruments through the program ’s amplifier simulations ( or employ those simulation after the fact ) as well as apply event to that pawn . But many people missed these characteristic as they were n’t easy to chance . GarageBand ’ 09 includes port change that make many feature more obvious ( as I discuss later ) , and none more so than the guitar AMP and effects . Not only did GarageBand ’s designers bring these guitar feature to the stem , but they completely rebuilt the AMP and effect from the ground up .
These feature are find in the new Electric Guitar track . These tracks are material instrument tracks that place one of five ampere simulation ( mould after Marshall , Mesa Boogie , Vox , and Fender Combo and Tweed ampere ) front and heart . you’re able to easily change amps as well as adjust the configurations of each adenylic acid — the amps carry knob for line up Gain , Bass , Mids , Treble , Presence , Master , Output , Reverb , Tremolo Rate , and Tremolo deepness . ( Those who find oneself adjusting virtual knobs clumsy with a shiner will be happy to memorize that you could snap on a pommel and then twist it by moving a mouse ’s scroll roulette wheel up or down . ) you’re able to also edit the amp ’s master echo and reverb options . The work that went into these A models is apparent — they go very much like the real deal , arrant with racket when you ’ve crank them up .
The new Electric Guitar tracks financial support modeled amps and stomp box result .
Electric Guitar tracks employ stomp box effect — effects modeled after the small effect boxes that routinely litter the floor around electric guitar participant . Stomp boxes include Phaser , Overdrive , Distortion , Fuzz , Chorus , Flanger , Vibrato , Filter , Delay , and Sustain . you may have as many as five stomp boxes at a prison term and changing the position of where the stomp boxes come along in the interface interchange the phone coming from the track ( so the corner work in successive order ) . Each stomp box include an On / Off switch as well as knob for adjusting the parameters of the effect . The stomp boxful also vocalize very much like the real deal .
You ’re welcome to make your own arrangement of adenylic acid and stomp boxes , but before you do you might care to examine one of the 37 include presets . If you desire to sound like The Edge from the early ’ 90s , for good example , choose Dublin Delay . Dick Dale wannabes can dial in Surf , which features the Combo amp with a middling act of amp reverb and tremolo and a Sustain stomp corner .
Before you toss your outboard power train in party favour of GarageBand ’s amps and stomp boxes , mark this all-important omission — like much of the rest of GarageBand , amps and stomp box ca n’t be controlled via MIDI , and that ’s a disgrace . Guitar players like to kick in effects as they play and the only way to do that in GarageBand ’ 09 is to take your hand off the guitar and click a stomp box ’s virtual buttons . you’re able to control parameters for stomp box effects after the fact using GarageBand ’s automation controls , but it ’s not the same affair . Electric Guitar tracks postulate some way of life to stomp a veridical switch while you ’re play and a MIDI comptroller is the substance . It ’s fourth dimension , Apple .
Additional enhancements
Magic GarageBand has seen some require improvements . While the set is still limited to the same nine songs as before , you could now register what you bet and export that recording as a multitrack task in the common GarageBand user interface . You also have the ability to shuffle the championship instruments by clicking anywhere other than on an cat’s-paw . This makes for some unexpected ( and sometimes welcome ) combinations . you may also now commix the levels of each tool as well as cursorily mute or solo each one with the click of a clit . And you’re able to choose any software instrument sound you care as your instrument when playing through a MIDI keyboard . You ’re no longer limited to a handful of instruments as you were in GarageBand ’ 08 .
Magic GarageBand now lets you immortalize your part and combine the dance band .
last , Apple has rejiggered the look of GarageBand in helpful mode . It now suffer the same grey-haired tincture as Aperture ( ) and Logic ( ) . The New Project windowpane stop a broader variety show of projects including Piano , Electric Guitar , Voice , Loops , Keyboard Collection , Acoustic Instrument , Songwriting , Podcast , and Movie , making it sluttish to start with a guide configure for the kind of labor you want to create . For example , take Podcast and the resulting GarageBand window is live with Podcast , Male Voice , Female Voice , and Jingles trail . ( Regrettably , you still ca n’t have more than one GarageBand labor open at a time . )
When you add a new track , you see a redesigned window that lets you easily choose a Software Instrument , Real Instrument , or Electric Guitar track . loop are now found on the side of the main windowpane rather than below . Effects are no longer hidden at the bottom of the Info window glass but rather available from an obvious Edit tab in the Info window glass . And text is larger throughout the interface . bring together , it ’s easier on the center as well as easier to receive the functions you ’re after . Veteran GarageBand user though I may be , with the fresh interface I was able-bodied to find feature I ’d forgotten existed .
Macworld’s buying advice
As a musician and podcaster , GarageBand rest one of my preferent iLife ’ 09 applications — I’m able-bodied to pull compelling results from the programme without a lot of employment or worry . Nothing about the previous version change that . What GarageBand ’ 09 brings to the table is the possibility that more people — specifically those expect to get some economic consumption from a guitar or keyboard crammed in a press or electric guitar players assay a more authentic sound — will stick around for a second look .
[ Senior editor Christopher Breen is a professional instrumentalist and hosts the Macworld Podcast . ]
