TheSilicon Valley Toxics Coalition(SVTC ) — the same environmental group that drew the attention of Apple CEO Steve Jobs at the company ’s shareholder encounter yesterday — on Friday shot back at affirmation Jobs made about the company ’s environmental policies . While the chemical group initial charges were broad , they specialise the focus on many of the issues in their responses today .
Jobs countered claims that Apple did not have an good estimator takeback program by pointing out that Apple has had such a programme for four year , reprocess over 1,500 tons in the last class . The SVTC said in reply that while that may vocalise like a lot , it does n’t compare to the 5,000 tons that HP pull together in a six - hebdomad programme .
However , the SVTC did not counter claims that it made saying that Apple appoint for recycling , while HP and Dell did not . Jobs said that both caller charged for their recycling programs .
The SVTC also order Apple has been lobbying against state legislation in Minnesota and Maine require companies to setup take - back programs , a title Jobs unconditionally deny . The group says Apple hired lobbyist Dan Riley to oppose the State e - permissive waste legislating — the legislation lapse with the aid of HP and Dell , the group says .
After realise an initial title against Apple in Minnesota , the SVTC did not direct this issue in their reply today .
claim that Apple apply prison or forced labor in their recycling programs were categorically denied by Jobs , tell that Apple nor their married person use such working class forces . The SVTC countered saying they have proof .
“ Jobs has go under up a straw gentleman here , ” the SVTC response reads . “ By not make effective pathways for fresh , responsible for recycling for the vast legal age of their products in the waste stream , data processor producers such as Apple guarantee that a pregnant amount of e - permissive waste will be handled by recyclers who use prison house confinement for dismantlement of electronic computer . We have contacts inside the prison system who confirm that Apple computers and other products DO end up in the prison disassembly programs . ”
Jobs said that Apple ships primer coat - up plastics oversea to make new recycled plastics , but the SVTC foresee it ’s Apple ’s inactivity on this yield that “ assures that e - waste winds up in Asia . We know from allies oversea that Apple products do end up in China and India , send off there via disreputable ‘ recyclers , ’ ” according to the response from the group .
call the SVTC ’s call that the iPod “ a sentence - turkey for our wellness , ” unforgivable , Jobs did say that there is a modest amount of lead in the iPod , which the company is working to get rid of .
“ Even small amounts of lead can be very , very harmful , ” said the SVTC reaction . “ And because the iPod is so minor , it is much more likely to get thresh into the trash ( rather of recycled ) and cease up in the landfill . ”
The group also said that even though Apple has set up an iPod battery replacement programme that consumers would not take advantage of it , instead choose to “ toss it in the shabu . ”
occupation said yesterday that he thought the group was using Apple ’s visibility to win publicity for their own group . cite a report in theKansas City Star , the drawing card of the environmental group said they “ picked the iPod to go after because it ’s the hip thing around . ”
Apple voice were not immediately available for remark .
